MailbagReaction to school voucher columnTo the editor:
In regards to John Huebscher's column in the Aug. 1 issue of The Catholic Herald, I would like to offer the following insights. The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled in a 5-4 decision that school vouchers are constitutional. For now. In his article Mr. Huebscher pits the "wall of separation" principle against the "neutrality" explanation because it suits his purpose. He is forgetting that a little over a hundred years ago Catholics objected to the required reading of the King James version of the bible in public schools and rightly so. They won on the First Amendment in its implied "wall of separation" principle. There is another "principle," a cornerstone in the Catholic social teaching, that has been overlooked in this discussion and that is the "principle of subsidiary." It holds that government may and should engage in social programs that improve the lives of its citizens but not to the extent of diminishing the efforts of private citizens engaged in similar ventures. Nowhere does it say that the government should actively support or contribute money to private efforts. School vouchers aids and abets the decline of public schools in inner cities that are already in trouble. They are in trouble because of a decline of public schools in family supporting jobs, the loss of the manufacturing tax base, white flight to the suburbs, to mention a few. To want to leave that situation is natural, but impossible, for everyone. School vouchers makes it easier for the private/parochial schools to cherry-pick the best students out of the public schools with the help of the government. No one has been able to explain how taking one child out of a class of 100 and sending that child to a private or parochial school, helps the remaining 99. Jerome Joyce, Madison Pope John Paul II will not resignTo the editor: Those who predict that Pope John Paul II will resign soon forget that Pope John Paul II is a great admirer of Pope Leo XIII. In spite of several physically infirm years near the end of his life, Pope Leo XIII ruled the church with wisdom. His mind remained clear and lucid until the day of his death at age 93. With the model of Pope Leo XIII ever before him, it is unlikely that Pope John Paul II will resign in the near future. Charles J. Sippel, Waterloo In gratitude for contributionTo the publisher: Please accept my sincere appreciation for the contribution of $14,813.89 from the Diocese of Madison to the 2002 Catholic Home Missions Appeal. I am grateful for your efforts to promote the appeal within your diocese. The gift will help strengthen the Church in home mission dioceses in the United States and its dependencies. Please keep us and the people we support in your prayers. Most Rev. Paul A. Zipfel, chairman,
Diocese of Madison, The Catholic Herald Offices: Bishop O'Connor Catholic Pastoral Center, 3577 High Point Road, Madison Mailing address: P.O. Box 44985, Madison, WI 53744-4985 Phone: 608-821-3070 Fax: 608-821-3071 E-Mail: info@madisoncatholicherald.org Web site created by Leemark Communications. |