MailbagWe must strive to achieve peace
To the editor: Thanks for carrying Tony Magliano's column. He is a refreshing voice, unafraid to remind/ask us "what would Jesus do?" in situations faced by our country. However, Fr. John Catoir's article of 2/27 "Dealing with Saddam Hussein: Is war the answer?" [print edition only] was filled with inconsistencies. It seems he is parroting the administration's position for war on Iraq, complete with the faulty one-liners we are bombarded with daily from our own media. While he may be expressing the view of some U.S. Catholics, I don't think it does your readers a favor by repeating these simple statements. We can get this stuff by the truckload anytime. He asks whether those opposed to war "want peace at any price?" Has he considered the costs of this war, the dollars and the cost to our own security? For purely selfish reasons, this is going to cost us plenty. In 1991 we bombed Iraq's infrastructure, their water, sanitation, electricity, schools, hospitals, and factories and killed hundreds of thousands and displaced hundreds of thousands of others. There is something about the spectacle of the greatest power on earth assembling an immense army to smash a smallish state which has already been driven to its knees by a quarter century of wars and cruel sanctions. The pope is calling for more time for inspectors, for continued inspections: "it still remains an effective path that could lead to the building of a consensus which, if widely shared by Nations, would make it almost impossible for any Government to act otherwise, without risking international isolation . . . . War is never just another means that one can choose to employ for settling differences between nations." The pope's envoys to Iraq, the U.N., and to our president have all brought the same message: War kills innocents and peace is still possible. Here are my one-liners: Who would Jesus bomb? War is easy. Peace is hard. If we are a smart people, we can figure this out. Marilyn Kinsman-Kharbush, LaValle Pope has taken stand on warTo the editor: Although the current administration has demonstrated it has no reservations about slaughtering up to 500,000 innocents in Iraq, there is one person who has taken a stand against this plan. That person is Pope John Paul II. The pope has already formally denounced the proposed war, calling it a defeat for humanity, and also has sent his top spokesperson to Baghdad. I would like to know what steps the Catholic Church is taking to educate the congregations on the pope's message of peace. Gene Schubert, Green Bay Where are voices opposing war?To the editor: Where are the pro-life voices questioning/opposing a war with Iraq? Methinks pro-life as a title is as misleading as pro-choice. In your March 6th issue you give prominent space to a militant advocacy for war from Douglas Kmiec [print edition only] opposite the editorial page. You buried the pope's words opposing the war back on page 22. Figure! Fr. Tony Schumacher, Madison Thanks for counter opinionTo the editor: Glory, glory! It was so great to read Doug Kmiec's article on Iraq [print edition only] in answer to Tony Magliano's usual ultra-liberal dribble. Thanks for the counter opinion. Keep up the good work. Bill Bartz, Westfield
Diocese of Madison, The Catholic Herald Offices: Bishop O'Connor Catholic Pastoral Center, 702 S. High Point Road, Madison Mailing address: P.O. Box 44985, Madison, WI 53744-4985 Phone: 608-821-3070 Fax: 608-821-3071 E-Mail: info@madisoncatholicherald.org Web site created by Leemark Communications. |